Skip to navigation » Skip to content »

The Newsroom

Ouch! The nominee's pre-game injury

 

Sotomayor very well may be the first Supreme Court nominee ever to hobble into a Senate hearing room sporting a certain type of footwear -- the not-so-fashionable, not-by-choice kind.

It's a cast on her right ankle.

She's expected to arrive on crutches Monday, and then sit at the witness table with her injured leg propped up on a chair.

Typically, nominees stand up to stretch or leave the room when the committee takes breaks.

But Sotomayor isn't expected to be move much because of her injury -- and that could make for very long days.

She tripped last month while rushing for a plane in New York, and suffered a small fracture.
 
The burning question: whose signatures adorn the cast?

None, it turns out.

An aide reports that it's a soft cast -- the kind that can't be scrawled on.

 

-Liz Sidoti, AP reporter, Politics

FILE - In this June 8, 2009 file photo, Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor, wearing a cast on her right foot, meets with Sen. Mary Landrieu, D-La., on Capitol Hill, in Washington. (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta)

AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta


 

 

 

=======

 

You ask, we answer

 

Fri Jul 10, 7:00 pm ET

 

Pose your own questions to AP reporters and their sources by following @AP_Courtside. Here's what you've asked so far:


Q: From @Pdad
@AP_Courtside What will Nominee Sotomayor say about allowing cameras into Supreme Court Oral Arguments?

 

A: @PDad AP's Julie Hirschfeld Davis says @SenArlenSpecter will likely ask #Sotomayor about the cameras issue. No word yet on what she will say

@PDad AP's Laurie Kellman adds that @ChuckGrassley asked Samuel Alito & John Roberts about cameras. It's possible he'll ask #Sotomayor, too.

===

Q: From @bschwartz
@AP_Courtside some people want #sotomayor to be a diabetes awareness advo but justices aren't supposed to be advos. How does she mesh that?

A: AP's Liz Sidoti says whether Sotomayor wants to or not, she'll be an advocate simply by being known as a justice who has diabetes

===

Q: From @B4ADavid
@AP_Courtside Given the fed suit filed by MA (re: DOMA) this wk, should it go b4 SCOTUS, do we have an indication how Sotomayor would vote?

A: Hard to know whether the DOMA case will make it to SCOTUS, how Sotomayor would vote. Nominees keep their cards close to the vest.

===

From @AP_Courtside
Odd #SupremeCourt fact: Former chief justice John Marshall's bladder stones are on display at the Mutter Museum in Pa.

Q: From @beadinglady
@AP_Courtside Is that like KIDNEY stones? Just asking..

A: Here's the definition from MayoClinic.com

-Lauren McCullough, AP social networks and special projects producer

 

 

 

======

 

You've been briefed

 

Fri Jul 10, 6:45 pm ET

 

Voting on Sotomayor's fitness for the Supreme Court?

The White House recommends "Judge Sonia Sotomayor, Nominee for The United States Supreme Court -- Briefing Materials for the Confirmation Hearings."

The 129-page manual, distributed to every senator, highlights what the White House believes are Sotomayor's most important rulings.

Not chosen as one of her "Ten Most Significant Rulings:" Ricci v. DiStefano.

It's the ruling endorsed by Sotomayor and overturned by the Supreme Court last month -- and it's easily the most talked-about case of her record.

New Haven, Conn., scrapped test results intended to determine promotions for firefighters after the black firefighters who took the exam did not score high enough to qualify. The 5-4 high court ruling supported the reverse discrimination claims by white firefighters.

Elsewhere in the briefing book, the White House instead highlighted three race discrimination in employment cases that conservatives might like better.

In them, Sotomayor ruled against African American plaintiffs.

-Laurie Kellman, AP reporter, Congress

 

 

 

======

 

Puerto Rico for Dummies

 

Fri Jul 10, 6:03 pm ET

 

Sonia Sotomayor’s parents came from a small, Spanish-speaking island east of Florida, famous for its turquoise Caribbean waters, sandy beaches, and a sometimes testy relationship with Washington.

No, not THAT island. "The Island of Enchantment," aka the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

 


The U.S. won the island from Spain in the Spanish-American War, and Puerto Ricans became citizens in 1917, just in time for the World War I draft. The island became a commonwealth in 1952, earning its people the right to self-govern.

Like Guam, American Samoa, the U.S. Virgin Islands and that  inside-the-beltway island known as the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico gets only one nonvoting member in the House of Representatives and zilch in the Senate. Its residents can vote in U.S. presidential primaries, but not the general election.

Its roughly 4 million inhabitants remain divided over their status. A small minority still hopes for independence. The rest are split between enjoying the tax-exempt status they get as an independent territory and wanting to become the 51st state.

-Laura Wides-Munoz, AP’s Miami-based Hispanic Affairs Writer

 

 

 

======

 

SAY WHAT? A glossary guide, Take One

 

Fri Jul 10, 5:37 pm ET

 

Senators tend to sound like, well, wonks. So, we're trying to turn Senate-speak into everyday language. Here are some terms that both Republicans and Democrats have used -- and our take on what they really mean.

ACTIVIST JUDGE: In theory: a judge who doesn't just read and interpret the law, but who is willing to stake out new ground in terms of what the law should be. In reality: "a judge who makes decisions you don't like," says Julian Zelizer, a historian at Princeton University. Code words often used by conservatives to attack liberals.

RESTRAINED JUDGE: Opposite of above.

MODEST JUDGE: One who buries his/her personal opinions and political philosophies when trying to interpret the law. "In an ideal world, modest judges would read what the law is, and almost mathematically reach a decision while extracting themselves from the process," says Zelizer. Sotomayor's supporters have repeatedly been calling her "judicially modest."

-Nancy Benac, AP reporter, White House

 

 

 

======

 

In the hearing room -- what to expect

 

Fri Jul 10, 5:37 pm ET

 

AP reporters will be stationed in the Senate room where Sotomayor's confirmation hearing will take place. Have a question for them? Send it to us on Twitter @AP_Courtside. In the meantime, they answered this one: What are you most interested in seeing or hearing next week?

Larry Margasak: "How hard the Republicans go after (Sotomayor), given their perilous standing with Hispanics. Whether they'll stick to criticism using a few 'safe' Republican themes: abortion, guns, reverse discrimination."

Jesse J. Holland: "How she parries GOP questions on abortion, gun rights, etc., because it'll show how well she prepared."

Laurie Kellman: "Getting to know Sotomayor, because these hearings tend to be the most we learn about justices until they write books and/or retire."

 

 

 

======

 

Confirmation hearings: the drinking game

 

Fri Jul 10, 5:26 pm ET

 

The rules: Every time a Senate Judiciary Committee member self-promotes, take a swig. But water down those cocktails if you want to make it through the first day.

 

Senators like nothing more than talking -- often about themselves, not always subtly. And preferably, on camera.

Definition of "self-promote": self-serving rhetoric of any past, present or future endeavor that voters back home might like to hear.

Example: Don't be surprised to hear long-timers like Sens. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, and Sen. Arlen Specter, D-Pa., harken back to the good old days, "when I was chairman." Listen for name-dropping, favorite recollections of a moment of legislative glory and frequent invocation of a senator's home state.

 

To illustrate: Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., executed a sip-worthy line in
1993 during Ruth Bader Ginsberg's hearing. His first statement after "Thank you, Mr. Chairman" and "Judge, I welcome you and your family," was an aside about how Ginsberg got the call from the Clinton White House when she was in -- wait for it -- Vermont!

(Drink!)

Muttered then-chairman Joe Biden: "I wondered how you were going to get Vermont into this."

-Laurie Kellman, AP reporter, Congress

 

======

 

Let the show begin

 

Fri Jul 10, 4:46 pm ET

 

AP Washington Bureau Chief Ron Fournier, a veteran political writer, and Donna Cassata, AP Washington news editor and long-time political editor, give their take on what next week's Sonia Sotomayor confirmation hearings to be a Supreme Court justice are all about:

 

                                                                  
SPOILER ALERT: Sonia Sotomayor gets confirmed.

Barring an unforeseen scandal or surprise, the high political drama that is a Supreme Court confirmation hearing will push the New York City native further down the road toward donning the black robes of a Supreme Court justice.

So why bother? Well, there are many actors involved, many scripts and many motives that require this show to go on.

Let's look at the cast:

 

THE REPUBLICANS: GOP senators know they're going to lose, but they hope to set a benchmark for future confirmation hearings. Their message: We're not going to roll over. This may not be President Barack Obama's only chance to fill a vacant seat. The next justice to depart could be one of the conservatives, whose replacement could dramatically shift the ideological tilt the court. Sotomayor, on the other hand, would replace Justice David Souter -- a liberal for a liberal.

THE DEMOCRATS: They are bracing for the next fight, too. Democratic senators want to prove to party activists, particularly the online variety, that they are liberal and tough enough to deserve backing.
Democrats also need to show their new president that they're in his corner.

THE INTEREST GROUPS: It's all about the money. Win or lose, Republican and Democratic lobbying shops reach into their supporters pockets at a time like this, when their causes seem the most relevant.

THE MEDIA: Journalists love conflict, and there will be plenty of that.

On with the show.

 

Supreme Court

 

(AP Photo/Susan Walsh)

 

 

 

======

 

The Supreme Court and You

 

Thu Jul 9, 10:46 am ET

 

Don't just watch the hearing — get your own backstage pass. Tune in to Yahoo! News beginning Monday morning to join Associated Press reporters inside the hearing room where senators will consider whether Sonia Sotomayor will be the next associate justice of the Supreme Court.

 

AP journalists will be blogging continuously from the hearing and offering insight, context and perspective from around the world on the issues facing the court and the Senate Judiciary Committee. You’ll also find a doorway to some of the most authoritative coverage from major newspapers.

 

Want to pose your own questions to reporters and their sources? Follow AP_Courtside on Twitter and make your voice heard.